By: umenyiora

umenyiora — Sat, 17 Nov 2007 00:04:38 +0000

Brenner, Eli by no means does not deserve to be in the league. He is in the top 10 of QBs in the NFL. He is much better than your boy Marc Bulger. That is a ridiculous comment. Eli deserves to be in the NFL with brother and father or not.

By: Brennerd

Brennerd — Fri, 16 Nov 2007 23:46:34 +0000

Tommy, the only reason Eli is still in the league is cause he shares his last name with Mr. Peyton “Most Touchdowns in a Season” Manning, and Archie “#2 pick and 2 time Probowler” Manning. The Giants fans have a right to be mad at Eli. However, he has done nothing good to the Giants, who gave away (in a way) Rivers, Merriman and Kaeding to the Chargers just to have the Manning play for NY. Wouldn’t the Giants front office be clever and let Manning (who himself is a very cocky man IMO) just to stay at San Diego, not willing to play for them, and letting another QB, Phillip Rivers, start for the Giants. The Giants would be really different right now, and so would the Chargers. Giants would have used draft picks to build Rivers’ team, while the Chargers would basically be a 6-10 team. Tommy, wouldn’t you prefer the New York Giants led by pro-bowler Phillip Rivers and 3 additional draft picks than a New York Giants led by Eli Manning, minus those 3 additional draft picks.

Comments on: Giants Fans Enforce Mediocrity on Manning

By: umenyiora

By: Brennerd